Kentucky’s Favorite Halloween Candy Might Surprise You

Halloween isn’t just about costumes, haunted houses, or watching Hocus Pocus for the 14th time. It’s about candy! And let’s be real, some treats totally steal the show year after year. Whether you’re the kind of person who trades all your fruity stuff for chocolate or hoards the sour bites like treasure, there are a few candies that America just can’t quit. Do you agree with this list?

The Ultimate Halloween Candy Showdown

So, which candies reign supreme in Halloween hauls across the U.S.? After countless trade negotiations on living room floors and a few too many sugar crashes, the results are in. From chewy and fruity to rich and chocolatey, these are the candies America just can’t quit. Airheads sneak in at #10 with their tangy charm, while classics like Kit Kat and Twix keep it crunchy in the middle of the pack. Sour Patch Kids bring the sour-then-sweet chaos, Nerds add a tiny-but-mighty punch, and Skittles keep the rainbow alive. Then we hit the heavyweights: Snickers, Hershey’s, and M&M’s dominate candy bowls nationwide. But at #1? No surprise here! Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups still wear the Halloween crown.

Candies That Rule the Night

10th Place: Airheads
9th Place: Kit Kat
8th Place: Twix
7th Place: Sour Patch Kids
6th Place: Nerds
5th Place: Skittles
4th Place: Snickers
3rd Place: Hershey’s Milk Chocolate Bar
2nd Place: M&M's
1st Place: Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups

Nationwide rankings are fun, but let’s get local! What’s the top Halloween candy in Kentucky?

All Hail the Halloween King of Kentucky

Let the Northern Midwest have their Twizzlers; we're talking Illinois, Michigan, Missouri, New York, and Wisconsin. We'll pass on the red rope, thanks. And, move over, SweeTARTS! This sweet-and-sour classic has a modest fan base out west, with New Mexico, Oklahoma, South Dakota, and Utah proudly claiming it as a Halloween favorite.

So, what about Kentucky? Don’t worry! Reese’s still wears the crown in the Bluegrass State. In fact, it’s not just a local favorite; Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups reign supreme in 14 states total, including nearby neighbors like Indiana, Ohio, and West Virginia. That’s some serious regional loyalty. With its unbeatable combo of creamy peanut butter and smooth chocolate, it’s no wonder Kentucky sticks with the classic. Consider it a Halloween tradition as sacred as a front porch jack-o’-lantern and a spooky story told by flashlight!

What's your favorite Halloween candy?

SOURCE: DoorDash, allrecipes

Kentucky Halloween candy, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups Kentucky, favorite Halloween candy Kentucky, Halloween candy trends Kentucky, best candy in Kentucky, Reese’s Halloween popularity