Casey’s Pizza in Evansville Ranked Among Best Gas Station Pizzas

One Evansville gas station lands on the list of best pizza!

Look, I love pizza. The tangy sauce, the melty cheese, the sausage and pepperoni paired with all the veggies... My mouth is watering just thinking about it. Give me a hand-tossed or a thin crust - I'm not overly picky. Just put it on my plate.

If you're like me, you probably have a favorite pizza place, too, and who knows? It might even be the one that made Mashed's list of Best Gas Station Pizzas in the U.S.

Get our free mobile app

A Surprising Pick for Pizza Lovers

Mashed is known for its reviews, lists, and even recipes, but I was still surprised when I saw "Best Gas Station Pizza." I mean, I know that gas stations sell pizza, but I had never really put much thought into which one had pizza that was better than the other.

So I saw the headline, and I thought "ok, I'll bite" - pun intended. I opened it up to take a look, and that's when I saw it. One Evansville gas station made the list.

Casey’s Pizza Brings the Heat to Evansville

Not only did this gas station's pizza make the list, but there are five locations just in Evansville alone, not counting locations in Newburgh, Chandler, Boonville, Henderson, and beyond.

So, which Evansville gas station made the list? Casey's General Store. Mashed points out that not only do they offer breakfast pizza, but all of the other traditional combos as well. They even note that the website bears a striking resemblance to a pizza restaurant. Check out the vintage commercial I found for their pizza!

What Makes Casey’s Stand Out

Midwesterners can count on Casey's for breakfast pizza to start their day as they head off to the office or make their way to school... The standard cheese, pepperoni, and sausage creations are joined by Canadian bacon and beef pizzas, plus a make-your-own possibility that lets you decide what the right toppings are. With specialty selections like a slow-smoked brisket pizza with a scattering of sliced peppers occasionally, showing up on the menu, it's clear that Casey's takes its pizza game very seriously. - Mashed

Where to Find Casey’s Pizza in Southern Indiana

To find out which other gas station pizzas made the list (spoiler: there are several with Indiana locations), visit Mashed. If you want to learn where you can find a Casey's Pizza in Evansville, check here, then keep scrolling to see some of the best pizza places in Southern Indiana!